Interview Prep Techniques

In yesterday’s Platforum9 Session for law students and early career professionals, Andre McClean, a legal recruitment specialist with over 10 years of experience in London’s competitive legal market, shared invaluable insights on preparing for training contract interviews. Drawing from both his expertise in recruitment and his personal journey from law student to private practice lawyer and beyond, McClean offered practical guidance on crafting compelling narratives that resonate with interviewers.

The Three Questions in Every Interviewer’s Mind

According to McClean, interviewers typically have limited time—often just 20-40 minutes—to assess candidates. During this brief window, they’re trying to answer three fundamental questions:

  1. Does this person know their stuff?
  2. Why are they here?
  3. Do I like them?

Understanding these core concerns allows candidates to structure their preparation and responses effectively, particularly when addressing the pivotal opening question: “Tell us a bit about yourself” or “Why are you here today?”

Crafting Your Personal Narrative

McClean emphasised that the story you tell about yourself is perhaps the most critical element of interview success. “If I’m prepping people for interview, I will ask them, ‘Why are you here?’ And they’ll come up with something and throw a few bits and pieces in, and then they’ll realise that unless they’re one of the top 10% who’ve really thought about it and drilled down, they need to go away and just do a bit of thinking around that.”

He advises candidates to avoid generic, inauthentic responses like “I have always been passionate about corporate law since I was seven”—statements interviewers hear repeatedly and find difficult to believe. Instead, McClean recommends developing a conversational, authentic narrative that explains:

  • Your educational journey and what you’ve valued about it
  • What research you’ve done on the firm and legal sector
  • The skills and qualities you bring (with evidence from academic or extracurricular achievements)
  • Why you believe you’d be a good fit for this particular firm

This narrative should be concise—ideally one to two minutes long—and rehearsed enough to sound natural without seeming scripted.

Research Beyond the Website

While firm websites provide useful information, McClean cautioned that they can have a “blinding effect” with their polished marketing presentations that make it difficult to distinguish between firms. “If you read the website of any law firm in the top 200, it’ll all come across as really good. They’ve got good marketing teams… it’s all glossy, it’s all super positive.”

To develop more meaningful insights, he suggests:

  • Focusing on specific practice areas that interest you
  • Reading recent press coverage of the firm’s deals and cases
  • Exploring legal publications like Legal Cheek for insider perspectives
  • Using LinkedIn to research the firm’s culture and people (with a professional, appropriate profile of your own)

Perhaps most valuable is talking to someone with direct experience: “If you have spoken to someone… you can say, ‘I’ve done homework, I’ve read the press, I’ve seen some of your deals. But actually, I also know someone who worked here and they had really positive things to say about their experience.'” McClean describes this as a “trump card” that demonstrates serious research effort and provides insights that can’t be disputed by interviewers.

Show Your Preferred Career Direction

When candidates are inevitably asked where else they’re applying, McClean advises transparency within sensible parameters. “What they don’t want you to say is ‘I’m applying to you, but I’m also applying to Clifford Chance, and I’m also applying to High Street Firm in Newcastle,’ because that’s three very different cultures, three very different firms.”

Rather than listing every application, focus on firms with similar profiles and emphasise what specifically attracts you to the firm where you’re interviewing. This demonstrates direction and purpose while avoiding the impression of a “scatter-gun approach.”

McClean shared his own experience of being challenged during an interview at Linklaters when he stated his interest in corporate law: “The partner just turned around to me and said ‘How do you really know that for sure?'” His response balanced confidence with humility: “From what I know of corporate law… when the work’s on, everyone, it’s all hands on deck. There’s a real culture of teamwork… but I also said, ‘Look, I can’t possibly be 100% sure, I’m 22, I’m sitting here to learn.'” This authentic answer acknowledged his limited experience while showing thoughtful consideration of the career path.

Managing Challenging Questions

Interviewers often test candidates’ thinking abilities through hypothetical scenarios or by probing potentially weak areas of an application. McClean stressed the importance of addressing potential concerns proactively: “If I was sitting in your shoes, one of the things that I would have questions over is the fact that I’ve got a 2:2 from second year… I would just say this, it’s a year that didn’t count towards my final degree.”

This approach demonstrates self-awareness and honesty—qualities that interviewers value highly. Similar strategies can be applied to other potential concerns, such as gaps in experience or unusual career paths.

For technical questions or scenarios, McClean noted that while you may not have all the specialised knowledge yet, you can demonstrate your analytical approach and awareness of key concepts. For example, in a scenario about taking on a new client with urgent work abroad, mentioning considerations like “know your customer” requirements and anti-money laundering checks would show understanding of professional responsibilities even without detailed procedural knowledge.

The Art of Asking Questions

The final moments of an interview, when candidates are invited to ask questions, present a crucial opportunity that shouldn’t be wasted. “Whether you think you’re being polite respecting their time, they will want you to ask them a couple of questions,” McClean explained.

He recommends thoughtful questions that demonstrate interest in succeeding in the role rather than just securing it: “If this was for whoever you hire for this training contract, at the end of the six-month seat, if someone was sitting with you, what would success look like? What would they have to have done in those six months for you to turn around and thought, ‘I’m really glad we hired this person’?”

This approach shifts perspective from self-interest to considering the firm’s needs, showing that you’re thinking about how to contribute value rather than simply what you can gain from the position. Similarly, questions about what keeps a partner engaged after several years with the firm can provide genuine insights while demonstrating interest in long-term commitment.

Beyond Preparation: Making a Connection

While thorough preparation is essential, McClean emphasised that the final element—making interviewers like you—comes down to genuine interaction: “It’s a two-way thing. They’ll have questions for you. You’ll have questions for them too.”

Simple practices like making eye contact with all interviewers present, listening attentively, and responding thoughtfully all contribute to creating a positive impression. McClean also noted that sometimes unexpected connections can make a difference, sharing the story of a candidate who secured a training contract at Slaughter and May after discussing Leeds United’s restructuring as an 11-year-old football fan—only to later discover the interviewing partner’s office was filled with sports memorabilia.

Summing Up: Be Authentic and be Prepared

The overarching message from McClean’s session was that successful interviews balance thorough preparation with authentic self-presentation. While the process can be demanding—from completing numerous application forms to facing unexpected challenges during interviews—each experience builds skills that serve candidates throughout their careers.

By developing a compelling personal narrative, researching beyond surface-level information, addressing potential concerns proactively, and engaging genuinely with interviewers, candidates can maximise their chances of success in the competitive training contract market.

As McClean concluded, “You will have bad interviews,” but with persistence and refinement of approach, candidates can develop the skills needed to effectively answer that crucial question: “What’s your story?”

Related

Building Your LinkedIn Professional Presence

Navigating the SQE: Expert Insights on Preparation for Aspiring Solicitors

Interview Prep Techniques

Securing Your Training Contract in the UK & Ireland

Mastering Your Elevator Pitch: Tips & Tricks for Law Students and Early Career Lawyers

Related

Building Your LinkedIn Professional Presence

Navigating the SQE: Expert Insights on Preparation for Aspiring Solicitors

Interview Prep Techniques

Securing Your Training Contract in the UK & Ireland

Mastering Your Elevator Pitch: Tips & Tricks for Law Students and Early Career Lawyers

Reskilling for the Future: New Skills for Lawyers to Succeed

Building an Effective AI Strategy for Legal Teams: Insights from Jonathan Williams

Building a Lean Legal Enterprise

How Legal Operations Can Elevate Law Firm Performance: Insights from Vadym Kuzmenko

Selecting and Implementing Legal AI: Lessons from Bird & Bird

Developing an Effective CRM Strategy for Modern Law Firms

Legal News & Views | Law Firm Consolidation and Trade Tensions: Reshaping the Global Legal Landscape

How Delegation Can Accelerate Your Legal Career

The Spiritual Dimension of Peak Performance for Lawyers

Human Capital Trends 2025: Navigating the Future of Talent in the Legal Industry

Branding Yourself as a Lawyer: Building an Authentic Professional Identity

How to Streamline Your BD Activity to Be More Effective

Legal Hiring Trends: Insights from a UK Based Veteran Recruiter

How to Turn Your Network Into New Clients

The Division of Human and AI Roles in Legal Document Drafting

Everyday Leadership in Law: Why Everyone Needs to Be a Leader Now

Legal News and Views

Peak Performance Lawyer: Mastering Emotional Energy

How To Be Successful by Building Strategic Relationships in Law

Open Mic Arbitration: Launching a New Forum on Arbitration Trends

Why Pro Bono Still Matters in Legal

How to Leverage Global Connections to Grow Your Business

B Corp Certification for Legal Firms: Balancing Profit and Purpose

Is Legal Tech Making My Legal Life Better?

Is AI Making Lawyers Lazy or Efficient? A Legal Technology Debate

Peak Performance for Lawyers: Maximising Mental Energy

Change Management for Law Firms: Overcoming Natural Resistance

Leading Change in Uncertain Times: A Framework for Leaders in Law

How Law Firms & Legal Tech Vendors Can Best Work Together

What In-House Counsel Really Want From Their External Lawyers

Corporate Governance, AI and Cybersecurity: Bridging the Gap Between Legal and Business Worlds

Building Your Brand on LinkedIn

Baby Steps to Building Your AI Use Cases in Legal

Peak Performance for Lawyers: Optimise Physical Energy

How to Choose Your Legal Tech Solutions

How Legal Tech Enhances Efficiency in Managing the Board

Why Legal Design Matters: Transforming Legal Services Through Design Thinking

How ALSPs Are Driving Innovation in Legal Services

The Rising Tide of Cybersecurity: Why Legal Compliance Isn’t Optional Anymore

The Changing Face of Law Firm Partnership: Beyond Technical Excellence

Market Segmentation: The Missing Foundation of Law Firm Growth

The Growing Crisis of Global Corruption: A Legal Profession at the Crossroads

The Future of Legal Document Creation: Beyond the AI Hype

Peak Performance Lawyers | Part 1 – Introduction

Bridging the Startup-Legal Divide: Lessons from SeedLegals’ Anthony Rose

The Next Generation Lawyer: Navigating Legal Careers in 2025

Running a Law Firm Like a Startup: Lessons in Legal Innovation

The AI Crossroads: A Practical Guide for Law Firms in 2025

Bridging the Generation Gap: New Perspectives on Legal Team Management

The Strategic Power of Voice: Transforming Legal Practice Through Podcasting

Get early access
to our community

Shape the future of legal

Apply as a moderator by filling and submitting this form.
We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Get Early Access to our app

We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Please fill out your details

We'll get back to you within 5 working days