Getting the Balance Right: How Much is Too Much for Legal Services?

As law firms grapple with pricing pressures and evolving client expectations, the question of “how much is too much?” has become increasingly complex. A recent Platforum9 session featuring Hugh Owen, Partner at Kinstellar and Ron Given, former GC and Big Four consultant provided valuable insights into the nuances of legal services pricing, challenging conventional wisdom and offering fresh perspectives on this perennial industry challenge.

The Myth of “We Lost on Price”

“Don’t sort of just shrug your shoulders and say, ‘okay, it was price,'” Owen emphasises, challenging the common refrain heard in law firms. The reality, he argues, is more nuanced: Clients are often really saying “All things being equal, you were more expensive than they were, so I chose them.” The key lies in the phrase “all things being equal” – firms need to focus on differentiating themselves beyond price points.

As one participant astutely observed: sometimes firms blame pricing when they lose work because “it’s difficult to admit to some partners that it wasn’t the price… maybe it was the attitude and something else.”

The Client Budget Reality

The discussion revealed a fundamental tension: while law firms aim to maximise profits while preserving client relationships, clients operate within strict budgetary constraints. As Owen notes, “From the point of view of the client… they have a budget, I suppose, most of the time.”

The Evolution of Procurement

The landscape has shifted from pure procurement-led decisions to a more nuanced approach. Legal operations groups now bring a deeper understanding of legal requirements compared to traditional procurement teams treating legal services like commodity purchases.

Regional Disparities in Pricing Trends

A striking contrast emerged between markets. While the Financial Times reported a 40% increase in US legal rates since 2019, a participant from Croatia, noted this trend hasn’t materialized in smaller European markets. Owen confirmed that Central European firms face continued fee pressure, suggesting a more competitive and price-sensitive market.

The Big Four Myth

A particularly interesting revelation came regarding the assumption that Big Four firms have much greater sophistication on pricing. When challenged on this, Owen found no magic formula in his Big Four experience. However, he noted one key difference: “Lawyers are much less informed about things like [internal] cost,” highlighting how law firms often lack detailed understanding of their profit margins compared to Big Four counterparts.

The AI Factor

The discussion touched on how AI is reshaping pricing models. Owen suggested a shift from “time spent” to “time saved” metrics, potentially leading to value-based billing – though he acknowledged the industry hasn’t yet mastered this transition: “Obviously nobody really has got round to serious training or understanding of what value added billing looks like.”

Building Client Relationships

The importance of early client engagement emerged as a crucial theme. Owen emphasised that successful pricing strategies begin with understanding client needs before the RFP stage: “If you’ve left it to the point where you’re ringing up the client and saying, ‘Why did I lose?’ you’ve obviously left it too late.”

Key Takeaways for Legal Professionals

  1. Invest in client relationships well before pricing discussions begin
  2. Understand your cost structure and profit margins
  3. Focus on differentiation beyond price points
  4. Engage early and often with clients about their needs and constraints
  5. Consider regional market differences in pricing strategies
  6. Prepare for AI’s impact on traditional billing models

Looking Ahead

As Owen powerfully concluded: “My feeling is that whenever you talk to people [asking], why did you lose, they will say, ‘oh, we lost on price.’ And if you go back to clients for feedback, you’ll be often told you lost on price because you’re more expensive. What’s actually happening is that it’s not necessarily about price… You’ve got to really focus on how well have you convinced your client that all things are not equal.”

Related

The AI Crossroads: A Practical Guide for Law Firms in 2025

Bridging the Generation Gap: New Perspectives on Legal Team Management

The Strategic Power of Voice: Transforming Legal Practice Through Podcasting

From Courtroom to Legal Tech: Essential Skills When Evolving Your Career

Beyond Transactions: The Art of Authentic Client Relationships in Legal Services

Related

The AI Crossroads: A Practical Guide for Law Firms in 2025

Bridging the Generation Gap: New Perspectives on Legal Team Management

The Strategic Power of Voice: Transforming Legal Practice Through Podcasting

From Courtroom to Legal Tech: Essential Skills When Evolving Your Career

Beyond Transactions: The Art of Authentic Client Relationships in Legal Services

Mastering Legal Directory Rankings

Is Legal Tech Really Broken? A Fresh Perspective on the Industry’s Evolution

Innovating in Law: A Practical Guide to Change

Achieving Your Legal Career Goals Without Burnout: A Guide for 2025

Building Your International Legal Brand: Lessons from a UK IP Pioneer

2024 International Arbitration Highlights: A Year of Fragmentation

New Year’s Resolutions for Lawyers: A Strategic Approach to Growth

AI in Legal Practice: Blessing or Curse?

Business Planning for Small Law Firms: A Practical Guide to Success

Leveraging AI in Legal Practice: From Efficiency to Intelligence

Managing Business Development Across Multiple Offices: Breaking Down Silos

The Evolving Face of Law Firm Partnership: New Research Reveals Shifting Priorities

Working with International Teams: Keys to Cross-Border Success

Legal Directory Rankings: A Strategic Guide to Success

Building Your Legal Brand: A Young Lawyer’s Guide to Business Development

Getting the Deal Done: A Business Advisor’s Strategic Perspective

Building Key Client Relationships: Insights from Both Sides of the Table

Surviving and Thriving at Year-End: A Psychotherapist’s Guide for Legal Professionals

Innovation at the Core: Rethinking Legal Practice for the Modern Era

Ethics in Law: Navigating Professional Responsibilities in a Global Context

The Latest Trends in Legal Tech: Insights from the Frontline

Finding Your Ideal Legal Clients: The Art of Market Segmentation

The Future of Legal Shared Services: A Strategic Tool for Modern Law Firms

Introduction to a Career as a Legal Engineer: Bridging Law and Technology

The Path to Partnership: How Lawyers Can Make It

To Coach or Not to Coach in Law Firms, a Professional Dilemma

The Legal MBA: Strategic Choices for Law Firm Management and How to Make Them

Building a Career in International Criminal Law & Human Rights

Do Clients Hire the Firm or the Lawyer?

How to Dual Qualify as a U.S. Attorney

Lessons from the AI Frontline: How A&O Shearman Implemented Harvey

Special Skills for Startup Lawyers

Navigating AI Governance: A Practical Guide for Law Firms

How to Build Your Legal Practice Through Strategic Referrals

Getting the Balance Right: How Much is Too Much for Legal Services?

Technology is Only the Tool: The Human Side of Legal Innovation

Top 10 Challenges of Running a Law Firm

Dual Qualifying as a Solicitor in England and Wales: A Practical Guide

First Steps in Understanding English Contract Law

How to Do More with Less: Productivity Strategies for Legal Professionals

Introduction to Alternative Legal Service Providers

Why Small Law Firms Need to Move Quickly to Survive

Taking the Pain Out of Work – Wellbeing in the Legal Profession

Setting Effective Personal and Professional Goals in Legal

Winning Work in the Legal Profession

Why Lawyers who Provide Feedback Build Better Business

Expert Insights on Building Legal AI Platforms

Expert Insights on Building the In-House as a Service Model

How to Identify Leadership Talent in Law Firms

How to Study Law in the UK

Get early access
to our community

Shape the future of legal

Apply as a moderator by filling and submitting this form.
We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Get Early Access to our app

We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Please fill out your details

We'll get back to you within 5 working days