Arbitration and New International Commercial Courts – True Rivals?

Introduction

This session on whether arbitration and the new international commercial courts (ICCs) are true rivals was moderated by Velimir Živković, Associate Professor at the University of Warwick, together with Michail Risvas, Partner at Withers LLP, Matej Pustay, Partner at CERHA Hempel, Miljana Bigović, Senior Associate at Moravčević Vojnović, and Niamh Leinwather, Secretary General of the Vienna International Arbitration Centre (VIAC).

They were joined by guest speaker Georgia Antonino (University of Birmingham), who presented her research on the rise of ICCs, alongside practitioner perspectives from the panel.

Why ICCs Are Emerging

Antonino explained that motivations vary across regions. In Europe, Brexit prompted the creation of new courts as states anticipated difficulties in recognising English judgments. In Asia and the Middle East, ICCs were established to project an image of business-friendly jurisdictions capable of handling cross-border disputes. Marketing and reputation-building have been key strategies in raising their visibility and credibility.

Comparisons with Arbitration

While some ICCs may offer lower costs and quicker proceedings, they cannot match arbitration’s confidentiality or the ability of parties to select decision-makers. Most importantly, arbitral awards benefit from the New York Convention, making them far easier to enforce internationally. By contrast, the enforceability of court judgments depends on limited bilateral or regional treaties. Despite innovation, arbitration remains more trusted and embedded in international practice.

Practitioner Perspectives

Practitioners confirmed that ICCs rarely feature in their drafting of dispute resolution clauses. Arbitration remains the default option because of its enforceability, predictability, and widespread familiarity. Some clients may prefer the transparency of courts or find reassurance in a judgment, but most still view arbitral awards as stronger legal instruments. Overall, ICCs were seen less as rivals and more as modernised forms of litigation.

Current Performance

The caseload of ICCs remains modest. The Netherlands Commercial Court has heard about 30 cases since 2019, while the Singapore International Commercial Court has handled around 90. The China International Commercial Court has dealt with fewer than 30, many transferred from lower courts rather than chosen directly by parties. The Dubai International Financial Centre Courts are more active, hearing over 100 cases annually, supported by compulsory jurisdiction.

Judges and Representation

European ICCs are staffed by national judges and usually limit appearances to domestic lawyers. By contrast, courts in Singapore, Dubai, and Kazakhstan have appointed internationally recognised foreign judges and allow foreign lawyers to appear in certain cases, measures designed to enhance credibility and global appeal.

Outlook

Panellists agreed that ICCs are unlikely to displace arbitration but could serve as valuable complements. They may appeal to parties seeking transparency or those hesitant about arbitration’s costs and flexibility. Their long-term success will depend on building reputations, attracting caseloads, and developing innovative collaborations, such as Bahrain’s arrangement linking appeals to Singapore.

Conclusion

Arbitration’s enforceability under the New York Convention ensures its continued primacy in resolving cross-border disputes. However, ICCs expand the landscape by offering alternative mechanisms that, while not direct rivals, can operate in parallel and complement arbitration in specific contexts.

Related

Rethinking the Law Firm Model

How to Build Effective Client Interaction

What Do GC’s Really Look For?

Arbitration and New International Commercial Courts – True Rivals?

Why Sales is a Dirty Word in Legal?

Related

Rethinking the Law Firm Model

How to Build Effective Client Interaction

What Do GC’s Really Look For?

Arbitration and New International Commercial Courts – True Rivals?

Why Sales is a Dirty Word in Legal?

How Data-Driven Business Development Transforms Legal

Latest In Legal Tech Sales

Third Party Funding in Arbitration – A Dwindling Concept?

Why Flexible Legal Solutions Work?

Leadership and What It Means for Lawyers Today

GPT-5 and its Impact on Legal Drafting

AI Enabling Friction to Improve Accuracy and Learning in Law Firms

How to Build Your Personal Brand Within Your Law Firm

How to Make Your Targets in the Last Quartile?

How Are Arbitrators Appointed? Unveiling One of Arbitration’s Mysteries!

How SME Law Firms Can Prepare for the Impact of AI

How to Manage Your International Referrals

New Opportunities for Women in Law

The Board and AI

The Impact of US Ai Policy on Europe

Wellbeing Means Be Well in Legal

Human-Centric AI

Why do Law Firms Struggle to Invest in Change?

Generating Work in Unstable Times

Navigating the Legal Tech Recruitment Landscape

Expedited Arbitration – The What, How and Why?

Alternative Legal Career Options

Redefining the Lawyer’s Professional Identity

Legal Tech Literacy for Law Firms: Building Foundations for the Future

Coaching in Legal

AI Integration for In-House Legal Teams

Non-Lawyers in Arbitration

Bridging the Gap Between Academia and Practice in the Age of AI

Breaking the Taboo Around Money In Legal

Smart Tech for Smart Holidays

From Big Law to Building My Law

How to Make the Right Legal Tech Choices?

Beyond the Hype: AI Agents in Legal Practice

Sanctions and Arbitration: Navigating the New Reality

AI Literacy for Law Firms: What Legal Practitioners Need to Know

Southeast Europe M&A: Investment Opportunities in a Dynamic Region

Trust Me, I’m a Coach: The Opportunity for Coaching in Legal Practice

Lawyer Wellbeing When Handling Legal Tech Implementation

English Arbitration Act 2025 Reforms: Modernising London’s Arbitration Framework

Latest in Legal Tech Innovation: The U.S. Perspective

Collaborating to Build Effective Legal Tech:

The Italian Legal Connection: An Evolving Market Overview 

Commercial Skills: The Missing Piece in Legal Education

The European AI Act: Understanding Compliance in a Risk-Based Regulatory Framework

Business Development Support: A Catalyst for Legal Career Progression

International Arbitration Forum: Major Trends Revealed

Navigating Your Career in Big Law: Insights from Perkins Coie’s Ian Bagshaw and Natalie Thomas

Essential Legal Tech Skills for Today’s Lawyers

What Law Firms Are Really Looking For When Recruiting Trainees: Insights from Julian Yarr

Embracing AI in Legal Recruitment: How Candidates Can Leverage Technology for Success

Get early access
to our community

Shape the future of legal

Apply as a moderator by filling and submitting this form.
We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Get Early Access to our app

We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Please fill out your details

We'll get back to you within 5 working days