International Arbitration Forum moderator Dr Velimir Zivkovic, Associate Professor at the University of Warwick School of Law, also acts as independent counsel and consultant in investor-State, commercial and sports arbitration. He was joined by Miljana Bigovic, Managing Associate at DLA Piper in Stockholm, who represents clients in arbitrations seated in Sweden and abroad. Craig Connal and Nina Jankovic also contributed from their own practice. Together they examined how witness evidence is prepared, tested and weighed.
Overview
Witness evidence is often imagined as the make-or-break of a case, a picture drawn from criminal trials. Bigovic had yet to see an arbitration without witnesses, noting that parties want their day in court and must accept the other side having theirs. Connal was more sceptical about written statements. He recalled a conference straw poll in which nobody had ever relied on a witness statement in award reasoning, and suggested their main value is saving time, with cross-examination more likely to shape decisions. Jankovic said statements feature in around ninety per cent of her cases, but their weight depends on the case and the documents.
Credibility was the central theme. Zivkovic described sports arbitrations in which clubs obtained near-identical statements from contractually bound players, which tribunals routinely disregarded as padding. Jankovic argued that credibility starts with the written statement: lawyers should interview witnesses and preserve their own wording rather than impose legal language. Connal recalled a senior witness who, pressed on a controversial phrase, said “these are not my words”, and his side’s case fell apart. He added that tribunals tend to trust contemporaneous documents over recollection, and that a slick, heavily prepared witness may be less reliable than a hesitant one. Bigovic explained that cross-examination of experts focuses on qualifications and engagement with opposing views, while fact witnesses are tested on memory and demeanour. She stressed the cost benefit judgement behind the rule against asking questions to which you do not know the answer.
Preparation ethics remain uneven across jurisdictions. Bigovic described a flexible Nordic approach: explain the process and brainstorm likely questions, without full mock examinations. Connal noted that US lawyers may have a professional obligation to prepare witnesses, and that the line falls between highlighting an issue and changing what a witness would say. Jankovic had not seen the disparity become a practical problem, because tribunals have wide discretion and quickly sense when evidence is lawyer-driven.
Key Takeaways
- Do not assume a statement will carry weight. Tribunals may rely more on oral testimony and documents, so invest in cross-examination readiness.
- Keep statements in the witness’s own words. Legal language and identical wording can signal lawyer authorship and undermine credibility.
- Test every account against the documents. Consistency with contemporaneous records and other evidence is usually a stronger guide than demeanour.
- Prepare witnesses without shaping their evidence. Explaining the process and likely topics is widely accepted, but advising what to say is risky.
- Weigh the risk of open cross-examination questions. Unscripted questions can produce striking answers, but only after assessing the witness and the downside.