Jon Bartman, Founder of The Law Tech Consultancy, and John Lindsey, VP of sales at Aracor, were joined by contributor Raymond Blyd to discuss why lawyers hesitate to use technology that their firms have already chosen. Bartman brings experience in persuading lawyers to evaluate and adopt tools. Lindsey drew on conversations at a recent conference in Boston. Blyd offered a historical view of lawyers’ technology habits and a perspective on the AI market.
Overview
The session asked why adoption stalls even after a decision has been made. Bartman’s starting point was time: busy lawyers rarely have an hour to evaluate a new tool, and a pilot that lands in the middle of a deal, a case or a holiday will struggle. Top-down purchasing has largely given way to lawyer-informed selection, but that still needs enough lawyers willing to test. Lindsey argued that, even when time is available, AI has introduced new barriers.
Lindsey described a verification tax: the effort of checking AI output can feel as heavy as the saving. Unpredictable costs (token pricing, usage limits) and unfamiliar governance add friction. Bartman warned that pilots flatter technology, because teams choose simple, familiar use cases and problems only surface when varied live work arrives. He also felt lawyers tend to look for what a tool cannot do, so vendors rather than lawyers should be accountable for success, demonstrating complex tasks as well as easy ones. Blyd challenged the reputation for resistance: lawyers quickly adopted the fax, pager, and BlackBerry, with confidentiality the real concern. He thought it led them to choose what their opponents use rather than the best tool.
Lindsey saw encouraging signs: firms talking about scale and profit, valuing speed provided accuracy and governance hold, and lawyers already using AI in their personal lives. Selection remains hard because products sound alike; Blyd said many use the same underlying models, and Lindsey advised starting with a specific problem and fitting a workflow to it. Bartman said security reviews that once took three or four months have come under competitive pressure since tools such as Harvey arrived. Adoption is still mostly lawyer-led rather than client-led, which leaves smaller firms without a legal operations function struggling to scan the market.
Key Takeaways
- Protect time for evaluation. Schedule pilots away from live deals, cases, and holidays, and identify lawyers who can genuinely commit.
- Test pilots against realistic work. Simple, familiar use cases make tools look better than they will in rollout, so include complex and varied tasks early.
- Hold vendors accountable for adoption. Expect them to listen, demonstrate difficult tasks, and share responsibility for whether lawyers succeed with the tool.
- Plan for verification and cost. Define how output will be checked, and clarify pricing and usage limits before committing.
- Begin with the problem, not the product. Many AI tools look alike, so a clear workflow need is the best way to compare them.
- Make the business case. Speed matters when accuracy and governance are demonstrable, which supports scale and profitability.