Dmytro Fedoruk, Founder and CEO of Ranking Copilot, and Helen Foord, Founder and CEO of ELE, discussed how newer lawyers can build a presence in the legal directories. Fedoruk is a former M&A lawyer and law firm founder who built a tool automating directory submissions after finding them one of the most burdensome parts of practice. Foord has worked in the legal market for decades, and ELE specialises in directory submissions, website writing and research reports, including its recent Directories Dilemma report.
Overview
Directories are often resented as a drain on resources, yet firms keep submitting because nobody wants to be the first to drop out. Foord noted that a 2016 Legal Marketing Association study found 83 per cent of respondents thought return on investment was below ten per cent, yet 80 per cent planned to continue. ELE’s new research found every firm interviewed still submits, but very few have ever measured the return. Her view is that rankings now justify themselves: tenders and panel shortlists increasingly exclude unranked firms, and AI tools tend to consult Legal 500 or Chambers first. Fedoruk stressed that, unlike rankings in other industries, legal rankings are independent and cannot be bought.
Both argued that a submission should be the start of a data capture exercise, not the end goal. Fedoruk described it as the deepest record of a firm’s work, richer than billing or CRM systems and reusable in pitches and fee proposals. For newer lawyers, Foord said material movement typically takes three to five years: researchers triage the first submission, remember you in the second and take real notice in the third. She advised writing in plain English for researchers who are skilled editors but not lawyers, explaining why each matter is significant, and following category definitions closely, since flexibility comes with experience. A smaller but more relevant matter can beat a large, dull one. Referees matter more than many expect: they can be other lawyers, experts or referrers, and Chambers weights referee research above the submission document. Fedoruk added that non-compliant information, such as a referee not worked with in the last twelve months, is discounted or ignored.
Foord recommended a category strategy set at firm level, noting that new or small categories are easier to enter than crowded ones, and that both directories have categories for smaller firms. Large firms face a different problem: choosing around twenty matters from hundreds, often with internal politics. Foord suggested succession planning for rankings, so that a ranking survives if senior people retire or a team moves. The speakers differed in tone. Foord believes firms generally reach the level their evidence supports, whereas she described Fedoruk as more cynical. He estimated that only about ten per cent of law firms are ranked.
Key Takeaways
- Treat the submission as a data asset. The matter details gathered can support pitches, bids, website content, and client feedback, which makes the time more defensible.
- Start early and stay consistent. Expect a three-to-five-year journey, with the third year usually when researchers really notice you.
- Write for a non-lawyer researcher. Use plain English, a clear heading, and a short explanation of why each matter demonstrates the expertise the category requires.
- Invest in your referees. Choose people who will respond and speak honestly, including lawyers, experts and referrers, and brief them in advance.
- Learn the rules for every ranking. Requirements differ by directory and practice area, and non-compliant material can be discounted.
- Plan categories and succession at firm level. Look for categories where your genuine competitors sit and protect rankings against partner departures.