Private Practice vs In-House: Choosing the Right Legal Career Path

This session explored the evolving legal career landscape through the lens of private practice versus in-house roles, with a particular focus on early-career decision-making, skill development, and long-term adaptability. The discussion was led by Moderator Ciara O’Buachalla, alongside contributions from participants across jurisdictions.

Speaker Background

Ciara O’Buachalla began her legal career in private practice, training and qualifying at William Fry before moving to Arthur Cox, where she specialised in commercial litigation. Her career includes secondments to Pepper and Vodafone, an MBA, a role at Amazon, founding a legal AI startup, and her current position as AI Governance Manager at Logitech. This trajectory reflects a non-linear, highly adaptive legal career shaped by both opportunity and intentional pivots.

Understanding the Structural Differences

Private Practice
O’Buachalla described private practice as highly structured, with clear hierarchies, defined progression pathways, and strong supervision. Lawyers operate within large teams, and work is frequently reviewed. Early careers are shaped significantly by team allocation and exposure. While this environment provides strong technical grounding, individuals may feel like “a small fish in a very big pond”.

In-House
In contrast, in-house roles tend to be flatter, less structured, and more autonomous. Lawyers are embedded within the business, dealing with a wide range of issues often unfamiliar, requiring rapid learning and cross-functional collaboration. There is less immediate supervision, and responsibility sits closer to the individual. The role shifts from purely legal analysis to practical application within a commercial context.

The Rise of In-House Roles

The session highlighted the continued growth of in-house legal functions globally. This shift is driven by increasing regulatory complexity, which requires companies to maintain internal expertise, as well as a desire to embed legal professionals more closely within strategic decision-making processes.

Businesses are also seeking cost efficiencies and reducing reliance on external counsel, particularly for day-to-day matters, while global expansion has further increased the need for legal support within organisations. O’Buachalla emphasised that this trend reflects growing demand for in-house capability rather than a decline in the relevance of law firms.

Skills and Mindset for In-House Success

Three critical capabilities emerged:

1. Commercial Awareness
Understanding how businesses operate is essential. While an MBA can accelerate this, similar exposure can be gained through cross-functional work within organisations.

2. Resourcefulness and Ownership
In-house lawyers often face novel issues without clear precedents. Success depends on the ability to gather information, ask the right questions, and synthesise input from across the business.

3. Collaboration and Relationship Building
Strong internal relationships are key. Legal teams must position themselves as partners rather than blockers, engaging early with business units to enable progress rather than delay it.

Transition Challenges

A recurring theme was the difficulty of transitioning from private practice to in-house without prior in-house experience. Despite demand for candidates with both backgrounds, opportunities can be limited. Secondments emerged as a critical pathway to bridge this gap, offering practical exposure and credibility.

Legal Education and Early Career Development

O’Buachalla noted that traditional legal education remains overly theoretical and insufficiently prepares graduates for either private practice or in-house roles. Practical experience, particularly internships, was strongly recommended as a means of understanding different practice areas and career paths.

Non-Linear Careers and Emerging Opportunities

The discussion also reinforced the value of non-linear career paths. O’Buachalla’s transition into AI governance demonstrates how legal professionals can move into emerging areas at the intersection of law, technology, and business. Her experience showed that career pivots often arise from experimentation and initiative, and that setbacks, such as an unsuccessful startup, can provide valuable experience that leads to new opportunities.

Ultimately, the session highlighted that experience plays a more significant role than formal qualifications alone. Building practical exposure, even outside traditional legal roles, can be critical in shaping future career options.

The Future of Legal Careers

The discussion closed with reflections on broader industry shifts, including:

  • Increasing integration of legal services within business and consulting models
  • The impact of technology and AI on legal service delivery
  • The emergence of hybrid roles combining legal, commercial, and technical expertise

While the precise direction remains uncertain, the consensus was clear: adaptability, continuous learning, and openness to change will define successful legal careers.

Related

How could a $2 Billion Firm collapse? And could it happen to yours?

The October Legal AI Roundup

Why Should Anyone Choose the Law Firm You Are Chairing?

Agents, Rule of Law, and “Human Values”

The Cost of Arbitration: Is It Worth It?

Related

How could a $2 Billion Firm collapse? And could it happen to yours?

The October Legal AI Roundup

Why Should Anyone Choose the Law Firm You Are Chairing?

Agents, Rule of Law, and “Human Values”

The Cost of Arbitration: Is It Worth It?

Behavioural Change in Law

AI in Legal Practice: Strategic Implications for 2027

Pilot to Rollout: Getting Legal Tech into Practice

What does it take for agents to work in Legal?

How to Avoid Jail When You’re a Managing Partner

Emergency Arbitration: How Urgent Is Urgent?

Bespoke AI Compliance Programs: Building In-House

Leveraging Live Events to Promote Your Practice

Building the Business Case for Legal Tech

Why Legal Research Remains Core to Good Lawyering and How Tools Can Help?

September Legal AI Roundup

Become a Legal Podcaster

AI in Practice: Delivering Results in Legal Marketing & BD

AI Lawyer 2.0

AI Compliance in the EU: Foundations & Challenges

Choosing the Right Legal Tech: Where Do You Start?

International Referral Management in the Digital Age

Private Equity Investment in Law Firms: The Enemy at the Gate?

The Race for Your Ranking!

The Monthly Legal AI Roundup

SME Law Firms – What Tech is Best for You?

How to Become an AI Governance Officer?

AI Adoption in Law Firms: The BD Perspective

Intro to EU AI Legislation: What to Track?

New Careers in Legal Today

The Multidisciplinary Aspects of ALSPs and Why That Matters!

Career Development in an AI World

Is This a New Age for Alternative Legal Service Providers?

Theory vs. Traction: Real-World Impacts of the EU AI Act & Digital Omnibus

The Legal AI Monthly Roundup

Rethinking Rainmakers

Why Research Still Matters for Lawyers and How to AI-Enable It

BD for Associates: Skills for the Next Generation

The AI Spend Trap: What Legal Teams Should Buy, Build and Stop Paying For

The Analogue Summer Challenge Part 2: Who You Are When You Switch Off

A Comparative Analysis of US and EU Regulation in the Field of AI

Law Firm Partner Compensation: How to Build Fair, High-Performing Firms

The Geopolitical Challenges of Integrating AI in Your Law Firm

The Most Difficult Decision for Law Firm Leaders Regarding Business Development Today

The Analogue Summer Challenge – Part 1: How to Switch Off

Why an Open Source AI Legal Platform Might Be The Best for Your Firm

The Legal AI Monthly Round Up

Turning Data into Strategy: Preparing Your IBA Annual Showcase

Simulations as a New Source of Learning

Bespoke Compliance: Designing a Sustainable Framework

Is Contract the New Treaty? International Law Before Arbitral Tribunals

Latest in Legal Tech from Legora

How Law Firms Can Grow In 2026

From Law Firm to Fractional General Counsel

The Legal AI Monthly Round-Up

Get early access
to our community

Shape the future of legal

Apply as a moderator by filling and submitting this form.
We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Get Early Access to our app

We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Please fill out your details

We'll get back to you within 5 working days