Imposter Syndrome in Law – How to spot it and what to do about it?

Kara Irwin (lawyer and qualified executive coach) and Jaimie Sarah (executive coach and fractional CMO) moderated a Platforum9 session with guest Charmian Johnson (former global law firm partner and somatic trauma-informed coach) that reframed imposter syndrome from a purely personal confidence issue into a practical performance and leadership challenge in legal teams—showing up in preparation habits, willingness to speak up, decision-making, and ultimately time, energy, and productivity—while underscoring a simple core message: these experiences are common, workable, and far easier to shift when leaders create psychological safety.

What we covered

Irwin set out three guiding questions:

  1. What is imposter syndrome?
  2. How do you recognise it in yourself?
  3. How do you spot it in colleagues, and what can you do as a leader?

Throughout, the conversation balanced two complementary approaches:

  • Somatic (body-based) regulation, led by Johnson, calms the nervous system to reduce the intensity of threat responses.
  • Thought-based reframing, led by Sarah: notice “imposter thoughts”, challenge them, and choose more empowering beliefs.

What “imposter syndrome” looked like in practice

Johnson described imposter syndrome as a persistent sense of being a fraud despite evidence of competence. In her own legal career, it surfaced as:

  • Over-preparing for meetings, presentations, and seminars
  • Perfectionism and fear of being “found out.”
  • Holding back from opportunities, or saying yes and then “paying” for it in rumination
  • A constant background loop: last thought at night, first thought in the morning

Irwin explored how to distinguish imposter syndrome from shyness or perfectionism. Johnson answered that these labels often overlap because they can be different “parts” of the same protective system. The key is awareness and curiosity: noticing what shows up and when.

The nervous system lens: why it feels so real

Johnson’s central point was that many “imposter” moments are threat responses. Not a threat in the literal sense (no lion in the room), but a perceived threat: judgment, rejection, humiliation, failure, exclusion.

In that state, the brain prioritises survival over performance:

  • The body ramps up into fight/flight (or freeze), and we feel it first
  • Then the mind tries to explain the feelings with a story—often harsh, inaccurate, or catastrophising
  • When the emotional brain is running the show, communication and decision-making suffer

Her practical emphasis is on regulating the body to regain the front-of-brain clarity needed for speaking, negotiating, and client work.

The thought lens: “imposter thoughts”, not an illness

Sarah encouraged the group to move away from treating imposter syndrome as a fixed pathology. The word “syndrome” can make it sound medical and permanent. Instead:

  • Notice the thought (“I’m not good enough for this”, “I don’t deserve this”, “I don’t know enough”)
  • Reframe to a belief that fits the facts (“I’ve done this work for years—this is just a new context”)
  • Watch how the belief shift changes physiology and emotion

A beneficial insight: fear and excitement can feel identical in the body. The difference is the label. If the body is activated before a new challenge, the choice becomes: “I’m not ready” versus “I’m stretching”.

Practical tools discussed: what helps in the moment

Johnson emphasised fast, repeatable techniques to settle the nervous system before high-stakes moments—especially presentations and big meetings. She shared an example of a client who was considering medication due to intense pre-presentation anxiety; after applying a brief regulation technique (including bilateral stimulation), the client experienced a noticeable improvement in steadiness and confidence.

The broader principle: the more you practise regulation, the more quickly you return to calm focus, building resilience rather than relying on avoidance.

Leadership: why partners should care (and what to do)

A key intervention came from Ron Given, who asked the blunt, commercially relevant question: if associates are spending time in “unbillable anxiety time”, should leaders treat this as a performance issue—and what can they do?

Both Johnson and Sarah argued that leaders have an outsized influence. The actionable leadership themes were:

1) Look for patterns, not labels
Possible signals include:

  • A dip in billable time around visible work (presentations, pitches, client-facing moments)
  • Excessive preparation for routine tasks
  • Avoidance of stretch opportunities
  • Silence in meetings, reluctance to volunteer
  • Overcompensation: defensiveness, aggression, or arrogance masking insecurity

2) Replace judgment with curiosity
Instead of “lazy” or “not engaged”, try “something feels unsafe here”. Johnson’s rule of thumb: focus on what happened to them rather than what’s wrong with them.

3) Create psychological safety through real leadership behaviour
Regular check-ins, calm feedback, and an explicit invitation to discuss concerns make it easier for people to raise vulnerable truths. Johnson stressed that the leader’s tone and assumptions matter as much as the words.

4) Model vulnerability and growth
Sarah highlighted the power of senior lawyers acknowledging they are works-in-progress. When leaders normalise nerves, learning, and support-seeking, it punctures the “I’m the only one” isolation that fuels imposter thinking.

5) Notice how you’re showing up as a leader
Johnson warned that unaddressed stress can push leaders into micromanagement, indecision, or reactivity—behaviours that amplify team anxiety and reduce confidence.

A cautionary example: how leaders unintentionally reinforce imposter dynamics

Johnson shared a formative experience from early in her career: she declined to volunteer for a major conference because she knew it would ruin her holiday with anticipatory worry. A partner responded by calling her a “disappointment”, rather than asking what was behind the hesitation. The takeaway was not about blame, but about impact: without a safe space, people suppress concerns, avoid opportunities, and carry the stress alone.

Takeaways you can use this week

  • If you notice imposter thoughts, name them as thoughts, not truths.
  • Before a high-stakes moment, regulate first, then reason.
  • In teams, prioritise curiosity, context, and safety over snap judgment.
  • Leaders: share one real example of your own learning edge—done well, it permits others to grow.
  • When the inner critic shows up, Johnson’s closing advice was to befriend it: ask what it’s trying to protect you from. Suppression tends to increase the volume; compassion tends to turn it down.

Related

How could a $2 Billion Firm collapse? And could it happen to yours?

The October Legal AI Roundup

Why Should Anyone Choose the Law Firm You Are Chairing?

Agents, Rule of Law, and “Human Values”

The Cost of Arbitration: Is It Worth It?

Related

How could a $2 Billion Firm collapse? And could it happen to yours?

The October Legal AI Roundup

Why Should Anyone Choose the Law Firm You Are Chairing?

Agents, Rule of Law, and “Human Values”

The Cost of Arbitration: Is It Worth It?

Behavioural Change in Law

AI in Legal Practice: Strategic Implications for 2027

Pilot to Rollout: Getting Legal Tech into Practice

What does it take for agents to work in Legal?

How to Avoid Jail When You’re a Managing Partner

Emergency Arbitration: How Urgent Is Urgent?

Bespoke AI Compliance Programs: Building In-House

Leveraging Live Events to Promote Your Practice

Building the Business Case for Legal Tech

Why Legal Research Remains Core to Good Lawyering and How Tools Can Help?

September Legal AI Roundup

Become a Legal Podcaster

AI in Practice: Delivering Results in Legal Marketing & BD

AI Lawyer 2.0

AI Compliance in the EU: Foundations & Challenges

Choosing the Right Legal Tech: Where Do You Start?

International Referral Management in the Digital Age

Private Equity Investment in Law Firms: The Enemy at the Gate?

The Race for Your Ranking!

The Monthly Legal AI Roundup

SME Law Firms – What Tech is Best for You?

How to Become an AI Governance Officer?

AI Adoption in Law Firms: The BD Perspective

Intro to EU AI Legislation: What to Track?

New Careers in Legal Today

The Multidisciplinary Aspects of ALSPs and Why That Matters!

Career Development in an AI World

Is This a New Age for Alternative Legal Service Providers?

Theory vs. Traction: Real-World Impacts of the EU AI Act & Digital Omnibus

The Legal AI Monthly Roundup

Rethinking Rainmakers

Why Research Still Matters for Lawyers and How to AI-Enable It

BD for Associates: Skills for the Next Generation

The AI Spend Trap: What Legal Teams Should Buy, Build and Stop Paying For

The Analogue Summer Challenge Part 2: Who You Are When You Switch Off

A Comparative Analysis of US and EU Regulation in the Field of AI

Law Firm Partner Compensation: How to Build Fair, High-Performing Firms

The Geopolitical Challenges of Integrating AI in Your Law Firm

The Most Difficult Decision for Law Firm Leaders Regarding Business Development Today

The Analogue Summer Challenge – Part 1: How to Switch Off

Why an Open Source AI Legal Platform Might Be The Best for Your Firm

The Legal AI Monthly Round Up

Turning Data into Strategy: Preparing Your IBA Annual Showcase

Simulations as a New Source of Learning

Bespoke Compliance: Designing a Sustainable Framework

Is Contract the New Treaty? International Law Before Arbitral Tribunals

Latest in Legal Tech from Legora

How Law Firms Can Grow In 2026

From Law Firm to Fractional General Counsel

The Legal AI Monthly Round-Up

Get early access
to our community

Shape the future of legal

Apply as a moderator by filling and submitting this form.
We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Get Early Access to our app

We will use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you. You can change your choice at any time by using the Manage consent link in this widget or by contacting us. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with our Terms.

Please fill out your details

We'll get back to you within 5 working days